IBBiology @Skyline High School

                                                                                                                                                                     

 

Design

LEVEL

Defining the problem and selecting variables

Controlling variables

Developing a method for collection of data

Complete

2

Formulates a focused problem / research question and identifies the relevant variables.

Designs a method for the effective control of the variables.

Develops a method that allows for the collection of sufficient relevant data.

Partial

1

Formulates a problem / research question that is incomplete or identifies only some relevant variables.

Designs a method that makes some attempt to control the variables

Develops a method that allows for the collection of insufficient relevant data.

Not at all

0

Does not identify a problem / research question and does not identify any relevant variables.

Designs a method that does not control the variables.

Develops a method that does not allow for any relevant data to be collected.

 

Experimental Design Aspect 1:  Defining the Problem and Selecting Variables

 

Background

Write a paragraph or two explaining why the experiment you are writing about is relevant to the study of biology.  How does it relate to what you are learning in class?  What process or phenomenon will the experiment support?

 

Research Question

This is a single sentence which clearly and specifically states the objective of your investigation.  For a Design lab, the teacher cannot give you detailed information and guidance.  Instead, you’ll be given a general, open-ended problem such as “Investigate the factors that affect X”.  You must do some thinking to recognize the nature of the problem that has been set, the factors (variables) that will affect the outcome, and how they affect it (the hypothesis).  So if a general question has been posed, make it more specific and relevant to your individual experiment.

 

If you're doing a controlled experiment, your research question must clearly identify the manipulated and responding variables for your experiment.

 

Selecting Variables

State variables explicitly, and explain why each is relevant.  All reasonable variables that might affect the outcome should be identified.  Indicate which variable(s) is/are manipulated variables (ones that you will change) and which are the responding variables (ones that will respond to what you did).  Indicate which variables must be controlled and why those variables must be controlled.

 

The variables need to be explicitly identified by the student as the dependent (measured), independent (manipulated) and controlled variables (constants). Relevant variables are those that can reasonably be expected to affect the outcome.

 

Hypothesis(es)

Although not required by the IB Organization, for many labs you will be asked to include a hypothesis.  A hypothesis is like a prediction.  It will often take the form of a proposed relationship between two or more variables that can be tested by experiment:  “If X is done, then Y will occur.”  (Examples:  “The rate of transpiration will increase as wind speeds and temperatures rise” or “Brand X toothpaste will be more effective in preventing the growth of the bacteria which causes plaque on your teeth”).

 

You must also provide an explanation for your hypothesis.  This should be a brief discussion (paragraph form) about the theory or ‘why’ behind your hypothesis and prediction.  For example, why should raising the temperature and increasing wind speed increase the rate of transpiration?  Why is brand X toothpaste more effective in preventing the growth of the bacteria which causes plaque on your teeth? 

 

Be sure your hypothesis is related directly to your research question and that the manipulated and responding variables for your experiment are clear.

 

Experimental Design Aspect 2: Controlling Variables

 

Control of Variables

“Control of variables” refers to the manipulation of the independent variable and the attempt to maintain the controlled variables at a constant value. You should write a paragraph in which you describe how the control of variables is achieved. If the control of variables is not practically possible, some effort should be made to monitor the variable(s).  State an explicit procedure or method for how each variable will be controlled.  (For example, if the temperature must remain constant, figure out how you will do this and state it.  Perhaps you might use a water bath that is maintained at a certain temperature.  Or perhaps the amount of light must remain constant.  In this case, you might take light readings before and after the experiment).

 

Experimental Design Aspect 3: Developing a Method for Collection of Data

 

Apparatus and Materials

Consider making a list of your experiment and materials needed.  Be as specific as possible.  (Example:  “50 mL beaker instead of ‘beaker’, type of microscope with magnification range).

 

A diagram or photograph of how you set up the experiment may be appropriate, especially for more complicated experiments.  Be sure your diagram includes a title and any necessary labels.

 

You might have to decide how much of a substance or a solution to use.  If so, state your reasoning or show the calculations.

 

Method/Procedure

State or discuss the method (procedure) that you are going to use (or that you did use) in the experiment.  This should be in the form of a list of step-by-step directions.  Provide enough detail so that another person could repeat your work by reading your report! 

 

You don’t have to go into detail about standard, well-understood actions such as measuring a temperature with a thermometer, weighing out a substance, etc. If a standard technique is used, it should be referenced. For example, while planning an investigation to study the effect of light wavelength on the rate of photosynthesis in Cabomba, the student may have adapted a method to measure the rate of photosynthesis taken from a textbook. A standard reference would then be expected as a footnote, for example, “Freeland, PW (1985) Problems in Practical Advanced Level Biology, Hodder and Stoughton.” Or the student may adapt a general protocol provided by a teacher in a previous investigation. The reference may appear as: von Bargen, G (2007) “Studying the rate of photosynthesis” worksheet.

 

If you do something in your procedure to minimize an anticipated error, mention this as well.  (Example:  “Carefully cutting plant stem under water to reduce affect of air on transpiration rate.”) 

 

In your method, clearly state how you will collect data.  What measuring device will you use, what data will you record, and when?  Or what qualitative observations will you look for (such as color change) and what will you do when you see this happen?

 

Multiple Trials

The procedure must allow collection of sufficient relevant data.  The definition of “sufficient relevant data” depends on the context. The planned investigation should anticipate the collection of sufficient data so that the aim or research question can be suitably addressed and an evaluation of the reliability of the data can be made.

 

As a rule, the lower limit is five measurements, or a sample size of five. Very small samples run from 5 to 20, small samples run from 20 to 30, and big samples run from 30 upwards. Obviously, this will vary within the limits of the time available for an investigation.

 

If a reading is particularly different from the others, it may be left out of the processing and analysis. However, you must always justify why they have chosen to do this.

 

The data range and amount of data in that range are also important. For example, when trying to determine the optimum pH of an enzyme, using a range of pH values between 6 and 8 would be insufficient. Using a range of values between 3 and 10 would be better, but would also be insufficient if only three different pH values were tested in that range.

 

Safety

List any safety precautions that must be taken during the lab.

·         “Wear safety goggles throughout experiment.”

·         “Be cautious in using strong acids/bases.  Rinse off spills with water immediately.”

·         “Avoid breathing vapors of automobile exhaust.”

 

 

 

"When we tug at a simple thing in nature, we find it attached to the rest of the world."  John Muir